Difference between revisions of "International Tron World Cup"

From Armagetron
Line 39: Line 39:
 
:I understand peoples' concerns about the fairness of the competition, but please bear with us: we're new to this! We will have clearer rules set out in plenty of time for the next Tron World Cup and I hope people will give us constructive feedback on them so that any problems can be ironed out before the start of the competition. --[[User:Dez|Dez]] 17:57, 27 July 2006 (CDT)
 
:I understand peoples' concerns about the fairness of the competition, but please bear with us: we're new to this! We will have clearer rules set out in plenty of time for the next Tron World Cup and I hope people will give us constructive feedback on them so that any problems can be ironed out before the start of the competition. --[[User:Dez|Dez]] 17:57, 27 July 2006 (CDT)
 
:Um fairness?? where was teh fairness in uk vs a1...or germany vs nafta?? in a way changing something to make it "fair" isn't very fair for the others who have already played...is it?  --BlAzE
 
:Um fairness?? where was teh fairness in uk vs a1...or germany vs nafta?? in a way changing something to make it "fair" isn't very fair for the others who have already played...is it?  --BlAzE
 +
:: Would now be a good time to mention that Legit was banned from the server when we asked him to join?  I'm willing to allow for being new to running a tournament if you're willing to learn from other tournaments, and there have been 2 recent tournaments that have learned these lessons already.  I'm starting to lean towards the Kill NAFTA Conspiracy theory myself, you may have been fair Dez, but it was Ady-Lucifer watching over the NAFTA/Germany match, and if you ask me, the NAFTA team played waaaay better than the Germany team, even if we lost.  Ideally, you'd want the team that plays the best to be the team that wins the match, and in a point-based system you already have problems determining that.  Then throwing on additional advantages to one team skewers the result even further.  If they played so well as to deserve to advance, the point spread shouldn't be as close as it was.  --[[User:Lucifer|Lucifer]] 23:14, 27 July 2006 (CDT)
  
 
== Teams ==
 
== Teams ==

Revision as of 00:14, 28 July 2006

Rules

All fortress players can participate in this tournament. Just post your name under the name of your country. Please write your name without clan tags.

This is organized in countries, if your country isn't here, edit this page and add it. It will be nice if you respect the alphabetic order. The country has to exist!!! Maybe if the team grows a lot it can make 2 teams, like east and west, it goes 4 usa :P, plz no invented names.

After all interested players register we will update this page with all the instructions of the tournament. Meanwhile here are some details:

The main plan is that it will be a fortress tournament, played in play-offs mode, when teams are ready, there will be a picture showing the brackets of the road to Tron World Cup. And if it is possible we will try to respect football world cup brackets :D

In case of some countries goes short, there will be a alliances, the way they will be is trying to join to another geo-near (example: spain+portugal->iberia, austria+switc->alps, nordics, ...) or just fusion with other short team (we will try to respect issues like belgium and netherland one :P).

A short team will be one with less than 5 players, this will be the minimum numbers of players to play a match.

  • No more players allowed to register
  • The specified country will play with the amount of players that have registered here.
  • All cw in TWC-ITW server, it has good pings for both,america has 180 ping, not so bad.
  • Suggestions will be considered on the next TWC in 4 months->>24 november

Further details can be found on the Official Tron World Cup Website

Groups and Brackets

Groups & Brackets


Comments/suggestions

I have a few suggestions to make the tourney a little fairer, 1. If one team has more players than the other team, the team with more should only use as many as the other team has.(min number 5)I thought that was standard practice, though I guess not. 2. switch between using a european and a north american server, so no one country has an unfair ping advantage. Maybe use US fortress for North america(good/fast connection), and stick with ITW server for the european server--Vanhayes

Thanks for the suggestions. My inclination is not to change anything now the competition has started, but certainly these things will be taken into consideration for the next world cup. Having said that, would NAFTA be happy for Vanhayes' change 1 to be implemented for the rest of this world cup on the understanding that there would not be a rematch?--Dez 18:11, 24 July 2006 (CDT)
Changing that player count rule, but not repeating the match that was messed up by it would strongly support the theory that the rule was pulled out of AdY-Lucifer's hat at match start for the single purpose of bashing down NAFTA. I see three acceptable ways to proceed: The best thing would be to get rid of the rule and repeat the NAFTA-Germany match, Friday would be a possible time slot. The two other possibilities would be to stick to the rule for the rest of the tournament, or to change the rule, but to remove AdY-Lucifer from the Spanish team to demonstrate the rule change isn't happening for his personal benefit (with eight players, his team would likely be put to a disadvantage by the original rule as well at some point).--Z-Man
i said that nothing will be changed on this twc.rules werent changed after the first match of twc , what re u screaming about z? -- AdY-Lucifer
Please sign your posts. -- nemostultae 20:38, 26 July 2006 (CDT)
I'm not screaming, SCREAMING LOOKS LIKE THIS. And I'm refering to Dez's suggestion to indeed change the rules during this first tournament. Let me elaborate, sorry if this gets offensive, but there is no other way of explaining: The player count rule is stupid and unfair, and a blind monkey with brain damage could see it. You were asked explicitly about how different team sizes will be handled on the forum (where you're not banned, btw), but gave no answer. The rest of us only knew the rule when it was, apparently, too late to argue. Now, there are two possible explanations: 1. You're stupid and incompetent and 2. you're corrupt, using your position of power in this tournament to put unwanted teams/players at an disadvantage. Right now, "Never attribute to malice what can be attributed to stupidity" applies, and explanation 1 wins. Should you however change the rule now, this would strongly suggests the decision to let Germany play with seven players was just an ad-hoc decision to kick out NAFTA, and the rule was crafted afterwards. This would give theory 2 a head. --Z-Man
What the hell, ady? We were told in the second match (USA vs Alliance 1) that we couldn't play with six because the teams wouldn't been even anymore. But now i see the Russia vs Spain match was played 6v1! This is really unacceptable. How can you say at one game that rule is 'play with the people that show up', then change to 'the teams have to be even' in the next game and then change back again in the third(+ignoring the rule that states a team has to have a minimum of 5 players). This only really supports Z-mans #2 theory since you were in the larger team of the third game. --Lackadaisical
Is this true? Spain vs Russia 6 vs 1? Are there recordings or server logs that can be reviewed? --Z-Man

Ok, it is true, their page shows it. Now, the question is, why wasn't it 5 vs 1? I see and believe that Sasha apparently didn't mind playing alone. But, in the Germany vs NAFTA match, we were told we were allowed to play with 7 people because NAFTA registered with 7; we showed up with eight, IIRC. Now, Russia registered with 5, so either I'm missing something here (perhaps you played with the implicit rule that you'd attack Sasha one at a time?) or Spain was playing with one player too many, according to the rule applied at the first match. I guess I'm not the only one who'd like an explanation. From DeZ, if possible, he seems to be the sensible one. All this doesn't make sense to me, unless I adopt one of the two theories as the most likely explanation. At the very least, the statements made here by AdY were *slightly* inaccurate and incomplete. --Z-Man

The problem here is simply that the rules aren't nearly clear enough and don't cater for the circumstances we found ourselves in. On the two occasions I was in charge (USA v Alliance 1 and Spain v Russia) I took the approach that it was better to try and keep both teams happy than worry about exactly what the rules said.
In the case of USA v Alliance 1, there were 5 players in each team during the first match. However, part-way through the second match, a 6th Alliance 1 player (a1|Goodkoen) arrived. I felt it unfair that he should join the team with the match underway and allowed the USA another team member (gengis) to balance the teams. Gengis was not from the US, but had not registered to play in another World Cup team. Both teams agreed to him playing.
Following that decision, I offered Sasha the option to make up numbers in the same way, but (s)he turned this down, opting to play alone. Following the rules here would have meant defaulting Russia on the basis that they didn't have five players. Given that people had turned up wanting a match and Sasha was willing to play, I let the match go ahead. Sasha came up with some inventive and entertaining techniques to cope with the onslaught of Spanish cycles, but the inevitable happened and after two matches of this, Sasha decided that there was no point in continuing.
I understand peoples' concerns about the fairness of the competition, but please bear with us: we're new to this! We will have clearer rules set out in plenty of time for the next Tron World Cup and I hope people will give us constructive feedback on them so that any problems can be ironed out before the start of the competition. --Dez 17:57, 27 July 2006 (CDT)
Um fairness?? where was teh fairness in uk vs a1...or germany vs nafta?? in a way changing something to make it "fair" isn't very fair for the others who have already played...is it? --BlAzE
Would now be a good time to mention that Legit was banned from the server when we asked him to join? I'm willing to allow for being new to running a tournament if you're willing to learn from other tournaments, and there have been 2 recent tournaments that have learned these lessons already. I'm starting to lean towards the Kill NAFTA Conspiracy theory myself, you may have been fair Dez, but it was Ady-Lucifer watching over the NAFTA/Germany match, and if you ask me, the NAFTA team played waaaay better than the Germany team, even if we lost. Ideally, you'd want the team that plays the best to be the team that wins the match, and in a point-based system you already have problems determining that. Then throwing on additional advantages to one team skewers the result even further. If they played so well as to deserve to advance, the point spread shouldn't be as close as it was. --Lucifer 23:14, 27 July 2006 (CDT)

Teams

Alliance 1 (Austria, Canada, France and Netherlands)

  • 1394-freak
  • JJBean
  • BaTTaL
  • Voodoo
  • k3nny
  • Lackadaisical
  • freako
  • Goodkoen

Alliance 2 (Switzerland, Portugal, Poland, Mexico, Italy)

  • Drashia
  • cusco (PORTUGAL - going away on the 28th for 2 weeks)
  • madmax
  • WebGamer
  • newbie
  • sebol158
  • the godfather (italy sicily player)
  • Tidus (possibly dont will be there)
  • ~Super Daddy~

Germany

Link: Team Germany

  • Fr34k(y)
  • Blader
  • PTA
  • Z-Man
  • ~*Mephisto*~
  • $ubzero
  • Slayer
  • H.A.K.
  • Sefgu
  • Tronfreak
  • Alien
  • Narrow
  • dyyXy!!
  • AshitakA

North American Free Tron Alliance (NAFTA)

  • Lucifer
  • BlAzE
  • anjori
  • BaTTaL
  • knojf
  • Vanhayes
  • Wrtlprnft

See Talk:International Tron World Cup for discussion


Russ.jpg

Russia

  • Ossi
  • Sasha
  • badzilla
  • doc
  • man2d


Spain.jpg

Spain

  • Ady-Lucifer (From Cantabria, aka Hell)
  • ORiON(From Seville, Andalucía)
  • ChiCho (From Motril, Andalucia)
  • Xevi (From Barcelona, Catalunya CAT.gif)
  • AuRoN (From Jerez, Andalucia)
  • ArcBeetle (From Cordoba, Andalucia)
  • Kakashi ( From Jerez, Andalucia )
  • Alf (From Jaén, Andalucía)

http://img140.imageshack.us/img140/4264/ukflag01rp6.jpg

United Kingdom

  • ed (From Wales)
  • X3R (be AFRAID!)
  • )(Alex)(
  • Infamous
  • Syllabear (From N.Ireland)
  • Dez (From England)
  • Sleepy
  • Pyroto
  • 2020 (currently in scotland)
  • Pez
  • Harlequin
  • Xell

@ Alex and Infamous, show some dignity. Temp ban of 1 day... would have been a week except for the fact you might need to post something to support your team --Your mom 18:19, 27 July 2006 (CDT)

United States of America

  • gArIsImO
  • Wildcat(Probably cant make it because of work.)
  • Goodygumdrops
  • Chuck (I'll probably make it, since I have no life and stay at home all day :(, What time EST?)
  • Dµrkå (99.99999999% chance I won't make it)
  • Manta (This is 1PM in the afternoon! doesn't anyone work?)
  • PsYkO WEWT
  • Pandemonium
  • Legit
  • eclipse
  • Stewie! (most likely will not make a very high percentage of not making it.)
  • Kyle (may not make it)
  • Oblivion Muahahaha!
  • Tits